Another World Was Possible?

Originally published in German on lunapark21.net as “Eine andere Welt war möglich?”. English translation by freetranslations.foundation, first published on Indybay, 13 April 2025. Translated without permission. By solidarity.

Criticism of globalization revisited

Another world is possible, it was once said. And indeed, it felt like a new beginning. Of course, there were also the cynics: that “different” does not initially specify a direction. And that everything could get even worse. And in a way, that’s how it turned out.

But back then – the protests against the WTO Ministerial Conference in Seattle in 1999, against the G8 summit in Genoa in 2001, or in this country in Heiligendamm in 2007 – the images went around the world. Not least because of the police repression, which even claimed a life in Genoa. But the fight seemed justified. And it was. Today, the upheaval seems very far away. What happened? And above all: How can we move forward from here?

Outrage I

There has been plenty of reason for outrage. It was impossible to overlook the fact that the amenities in the Global North had been bought with blatant injustice in the Global South, even if we probably still cannot grasp all the details today. It also did not go unnoticed that by no means everyone in the Global North benefits from the conveniences of the global networking of goods and financial flows. Nevertheless, this outcry was apparently needed: “Empört Euch” (Be outraged). Well, literally, this outcry only occurred in 2010, when Stéphane Hessel made a statement to that effect. The founding of the quintessential globalization critique, the network Attac, in 1998, was the result of an editorial by Ignacio Ramonet, who, in an article titled “Defusing the Markets,” revisited the idea of the Tobin tax to regulate the financial markets and proposed a plan to attempt a worldwide implementation by founding a network of NGOs.

Tax as a form of control

The idea of a Tobin tax dates back to the 1970s and is named after its inventor: the US-American economist and Nobel Prize winner James Tobin (1918 – 2002). His goal was to “throw a spanner in the works” of global financial markets in order to increase their stability. The Tobin tax envisages a small levy on every currency transaction. This would make speculative, short-term trading more expensive, while long-term investments would hardly be affected. When it was founded, the Attac network set itself the task of implementing this tax at the global level. Incidentally, however, here Attac’s critics of globalization go beyond the inventor’s proposals: the tax would open up new sources of revenue for public investment and development aid.

Larger-scale implementation has not yet been successful. A sufficient number of national governments would have to agree and act together for the benefit of the world’s population. One may suspect: if that were to succeed, it could set a precedent. And suddenly we would have nothing but agreements for the benefit of the world population. Apparently, there are forces for which such a prospect spoils the good mood. And apparently, these forces are still well positioned.

Freedom of movement for whom?

Criticism of globalization has not stopped at financial market instruments. The problems associated with globalization are not limited to the financial markets either.

The problematic effects of the policies of the IMF, World Bank and WTO, which are dominated by the governments of the particularly influential industrialized nations of the Global North, are still an issue. Their structural adjustment programs trap developing countries in debt and exacerbate economic dependencies as well as social inequalities. The power structures of transnational corporations, which blackmail states and undermine democratic decision-making processes, are still an issue. It is undisputed that globalization is not neutral, but is shaped by economic and political power relations that exacerbate inequalities.

Since the early 2000s, the conditions for social change have changed. After the 2008 financial crisis, criticism of globalization was briefly back at the center of the debate, but capitalism has proven to be extremely adaptable. New crises – from the pandemic to the war in Ukraine – have diverted political attention to other issues. Digitization has created new, well-financed companies that largely escape democratic control. Tech giants such as Amazon, Google, Facebook, and the Musk empire influence not only the market but also political processes, opinion-forming and social movements. In addition, authoritarian, nationalist currents have gained influence, responding to social inequality not with a more just globalization, but with isolation and protectionism.

In the run-up to the early parliamentary elections in February, the defining campaign issue for most parties in this country was the extent to which migration should be combated. We can state that on closer inspection, it is nonsense to discuss the question of flight and migration while leaving the rest of the world – which, after all, produces the causes of flight – unchanged. The structure of world trade in favor of the Global North and to the detriment of the Global South, with all the consequential damage on the ground, plays a role here that should not be neglected.

Outrage II

The question of a better world need not be treated as an altruistic one. You could also formulate it in a very, very selfish way: precisely because I want things to go well and better for me and mine, I must want things to go well and better for everyone else; I must want struggles over distribution to be no longer necessary. The only reason to see it differently would be if I thought my own greed was limitless, and therefore had to think the greed of others was limitless too. In that case, distribution struggles would be inevitable. It is hard to overlook the fact that boundless greed exists. But to assume that it is the norm, the basis for the world we live in – can we talk about that again?

We live in a time when the richest man in the world can buy a US president. At the same time, we talk about overburdened state and national budgets as if the distribution of resources were a law of nature. Utopias are a tricky thing. They don’t automatically get closer just because time moves forward. But hope begins with our ability to imagine a better future at all. In this sense: another world is possible.

Workers of the World, Divide?

Originally published in Lunapark21, issue 64 (Spring 2025) – translated from German (“Proletarier aller Länder, vereinzelt euch?”)

In the summer of 2016, a piece under the above title was published in the newspaper FaktenCheck Europa, where I explored the role of migration as a trigger for nationalist mobilization around Brexit. A few months later, Donald Trump won the U.S. presidency—following a similar script to that of the Brexiteers. By now, hardly anyone denies that Brexit has failed to deliver on any of the promises made by the „Take back control“ campaign. And yet, the right-wing mobilization left a lasting impact. By the time the inevitable damages set in, they could no longer be easily undone.

„Compete for the last job! Join your employer in the battle for market share! Realize that you’re too expensive!“ Donald Trump’s speech before both houses of the U.S. Congress on March 4, 2025, didn’t include these exact words, but it certainly conveyed their meaning. From Elon Musk’s attacks on social benefits and public service workers to the tariff hikes, from claims on foreign territory to the blatant extortion of Ukraine, the U.S. president proudly listed all he has achieved and still aims to achieve.

Reshuffling the World

Commentators are fond of calling Donald Trump a narcissist. But that doesn’t mean he’s the only one who thinks he’s great. His program has a societal base: corporate leaders eager to secure their place in the redivision of global spheres of influence. They rearrange their capital assets and aim to restructure the world with the help of politics. Some observers have even described the process as a “defragmentation” of the global economy.

Users of older Windows computers may still recall the term. The operating system had a tendency to scatter fragments of edited files across the hard drive. Again and again users had to run a defragmentation tool if they didn’t want to wait too long for applications to load. The world economy, after decades of globalization, now shows a high degree of fragmentation. The production of everyday goods is distributed across hundreds of producers in dozens of countries—depending on the most profitable conditions. Across the globe, people cooperate under corporate command, in the name of higher profits. But rising geopolitical uncertainty has cast doubt on this division of labor. A more direct control is the new objective: control over production, over supply chains, over people. Trump’s deportation schemes and tighter border regimes are designed to ensure no one escapes their assigned place in the global hierarchy of inequality.

Some don’t want to escape their assigned places—because some of those places are rather comfortable. And they are fiercely defended. Back in the 2008 financial crisis, the buzzword for key players was “systemic relevance”—“too big to fail.” These days, banks are no longer the stars of the business pages. Even well-informed observers have to look up the name of the U.S. Treasury Secretary—Scott Bessent, billionaire, long-time manager for George Soros. But Trump’s supporters are no longer just IT billionaires. They now include Jamie Dimon, CEO of JPMorgan Chase, the largest U.S. bank. He recently declared an end to his business quarrels with Elon Musk, calling Trump’s tariff hikes no real problem—if only the rest of the world would finally accept them. Yet even Dimon sees cause for concern in rising inflation and global tensions. He has already issued a pre-emptive warning to his shareholders. As for Wall Street’s own role in creating these risks—such as backing a president both pro-capital and authoritarian—he had nothing to say.

Not that the shareholders needed warning. Since April 2024, the markets had welcomed the prospect of a second Trump presidency with rising stock prices—the mere promise of continued tax giveaways to the wealthy was reason enough. But since early December, both the Dow Jones and the broader S&P 500 have been treading water. Trump may disregard the republican institutions of the United States—but he cannot ignore the mood of the capital markets.

The U.S. president has admirers across American society—as long as he is successful. And internationally he is not alone in his ambitions. Like Pope Alexander VI in 1493, Trump and Putin would love to divide the world between them as great men of history. Can they do it? Of course not. They lack the political, economic, and even military power to do so. But that doesn’t mean the current governments of the U.S. and Russia are incapable of inflicting massive suffering. Their power may not be enough to achieve their goals, but it’s more than enough for large-scale destruction. The hope—not only in Washington—is that other states will cave in to cheap blackmail.

Successes and Failures

In fact, even the apparent successes of this policy carry the seeds of its failure. Whatever goals the U.S. government hoped to achieve with its pressure on Ukraine, or with punitive tariffs on Mexico, Canada and China—Donald Trump has, at the very least, succeeded in one long-term goal: European NATO states are rearming. The British Prime Minister is coordinating weapons deliveries to Ukraine. The European Commission is looking to lift the Maastricht restrictions to facilitate national defense plans, mobilizing around 650 billion euros. Additionally, the Commission plans a coordinated procurement program worth 150 billion euros. In Germany, the conservative CDU and the Social Democrats have have joined forces to exempt massive military spending from constitutional debt brake. Trump has won. Yet the rearmament of Europe’s NATO members today is not a contribution to the transatlantic alliance—it is a signal of profound distrust toward the former leader of the free world.

These are the conflicts fought between competing elites. Are there any others? Although majorities in most countries are clearly opposed to war, it has no effect. Wars are started by those in power. And as long as the powerful are not stopped from ruling, wars will end—if at all—on their terms. How could wars be prevented by populations who have been losing the struggle for a modest livelihood for decades, disorganized and without a shared vision of a more hopeful future?

Today’s international politics are built on the defeats of the labor movements in the industrial countries of East and West—and the defeats of anti-colonial liberation movements in the Global South. Organizations attempting to independently articulate the interests of the working classes in their own countries rarely gain national, let alone international significance. As a result, the class struggle has vanished from the global political stage. It will not return through nostalgia for the good old days and their colorfully painted enemy stereotypes. It will return through the fight for peace, here and abroad, for health and clean water, for decent housing and smart textbooks, for free work and free time.